An earlier article on this website compared Transactional Analysis with the work of Jay Greenberg. This article addresses a different author: Elinor Greenberg, whose book Borderline, Narcissistic, and Schizoid Adaptations explores how people organise their relationships around the pursuit of love, admiration or safety. The two Greenbergs should not be confused.
What happens when closeness is wanted, but also feels dangerous?
For some people, connection with another person can bring an uneasy sense of being crowded, controlled or overwhelmed. Stepping back may offer relief. Yet too much distance can bring loneliness, or the feeling of watching life from somewhere outside it.
Both Elinor Greenberg’s writing and the Transactional Analysis tradition offer ways of thinking about this tension through the idea of a schizoid adaptation. Neither suggests that withdrawal is simply a lack of interest in other people. Each asks what purpose distance might serve.
They do not, however, arrive at the question from quite the same place. Greenberg draws particularly on Gestalt therapy and object relations theory. Within Transactional Analysis, the personality adaptations model developed by Paul Ware and expanded by Vann Joines and Ian Stewart offers a different set of concepts for understanding how a person has learned to survive and relate. [1]
A note about the word “schizoid”
“Schizoid” can sound stark, and it is a word with a history in psychiatric diagnosis as well as psychotherapy theory. Here, I am using it to discuss patterns described by particular authors, not to diagnose anyone.
A preference for solitude, privacy or independence is not in itself evidence of a difficulty. Nor can someone’s history be inferred from how sociable, quiet or self-contained they appear. These theories are most useful when held as possibilities to explore with a person, rather than as explanations imposed upon them.
Elinor Greenberg: safety at the contact boundary
Greenberg describes personality adaptations as ways of organising experience in relationships. In her account, someone with a schizoid adaptation may be particularly attentive to whether contact with another person feels safe.
This does not mean that love or recognition are unimportant. Rather, Greenberg suggests that concerns about safety can become especially prominent: before closeness can feel nourishing, the person may need to know that they can remain themselves within it. [1]
Imagine being with someone who asks a lot of questions, offers advice quickly and expects an immediate emotional response. Their intention may be caring. But for the person receiving that attention, the experience might be one of pressure: “Am I allowed to take my time? Can I disagree? Will there still be space for me?”
From Greenberg’s perspective, withdrawing in such a moment is not necessarily a rejection of the relationship. It may be an attempt to preserve a sense of self.
Gestalt therapy pays attention to what comes into focus in a person’s experience, and what recedes into the background. Greenberg uses this perspective to consider what repeatedly becomes most pressing in interpersonal situations. For someone whose attention is organised around safety, a small sign of possible intrusion may become more important than other aspects of the encounter. [1]
This gives the therapist a question to hold in the present: what is happening between us now, and how might the way I am making contact be experienced?
Transactional Analysis: adaptation, script and contact
In Transactional Analysis, personality adaptations are understood as patterns that can develop as a person finds ways to manage their early environment. Paul Ware described six adaptations and proposed that different ways of making contact might be helpful with each. Joines and Stewart later developed the personality adaptations model further. [2]
The schizoid adaptation is sometimes described in this tradition as the “creative daydreamer”. Writing about schizoid processes, Ray Little connects Joines’ description with a capacity for thinking internally. The phrase can also invite curiosity about whether retreating inward has offered protection. It should not be taken to mean that every person who recognises something of this pattern will be a daydreamer, or that their experience can be captured by a single description. [3]
TA offers several ways of exploring how such a pattern is maintained:
- Script: the often implicit expectations a person has developed about themselves, other people and relationships.
- Ego states: ways of understanding patterns of thinking, feeling and behaving in the present.
- Transactions: the exchanges that take place between people.
- Contact: how a therapist and client find a way to meet that is workable for the client.
For example, someone may have learned an expectation such as “It is safer not to need too much from other people.” In therapy, that expectation might appear in the way they minimise a wish for support, change the subject when they feel vulnerable, or become wary when the therapist seems particularly interested.
These are possibilities to explore, not hidden truths the therapist can know in advance. A client may have very different words for their experience, or may not experience their independence as a problem at all.
Ware also described “doors” to therapy: ways of approaching contact, areas for therapeutic development, and approaches that may feel less accessible or less helpful. The value of the idea is not that a therapist should mechanically follow a formula, but that they should consider how their way of engaging may be received. [2]
Comparison at a glance
The table summarises emphases rather than fixed rules: practitioners within both traditions may work in different ways, and neither column describes every person who values distance or privacy.
| Dimension | Elinor Greenberg | Transactional Analysis personality adaptations |
|---|---|---|
| Theoretical frame | Gestalt therapy, drawing also on object relations. | TA personality adaptations, alongside concepts such as script, ego states and transactions. |
| Main emphasis | What becomes important in contact, particularly the need for safety and a sense of self. | Patterns developed in response to experience and how they shape present relationships. |
| Withdrawal | May protect the person from a sense of intrusion or loss of self. | May be understood as a protective adaptation; its meaning is explored with the individual. |
| Development | Considers how earlier relationships inform expectations of contact. | Explores how early experience and script expectations may influence later responses. |
| Therapeutic attention | The immediate experience of contact, boundaries and safety. | The therapeutic relationship, recurring transactions, script and ways of making contact. |
| Shared aim | Support contact that does not come at the expense of the person’s sense of self. | Support greater awareness and choice without dismissing the protective purpose of the adaptation. |
The distinctions draw on Greenberg’s account and Ware’s model; the final row expresses an integrative reading rather than an identical stated goal of both authors. [1] [2]
Where the approaches meet
The most important shared ground is the idea of adaptation. Both perspectives invite us to look beyond an outward appearance of distance and ask what that distance may be doing for the person.
A person who leaves a conversation, becomes absorbed in thought or finds it difficult to ask for help may be responding to something meaningful in their experience. Rather than treating those responses as obstacles to be removed, therapy can become a place to understand them.
Both approaches also leave room for the tension between closeness and autonomy. Someone might want to be known and still need considerable space. They might feel comforted by another person’s interest on one day and overwhelmed by it on another.
Neither response needs to be corrected immediately. It may be more helpful to become curious about what changes, what feels manageable and what allows the person to remain present.
Where the emphases differ
Greenberg’s emphasis, particularly in the Gestalt account of personality adaptations, is on how experience is organised in the moment: what becomes most pressing at the boundary between the person and their environment. Safety, intrusion and the possibility of remaining oneself in contact are central themes in her account of schizoid adaptation. [1]
The TA personality adaptations model offers a broader map of patterns and ways of working with them. It can draw attention to a person’s script, their habitual responses and the kind of therapeutic contact that may help them engage. Ware’s “doors” provide one example of how the model translates these ideas into therapeutic approach. [2]
This distinction should not be made too rigid. Greenberg is interested in developmental history as well as present experience; TA therapists can be deeply attentive to what is happening in the therapeutic relationship. There is no neat division in which one approach is relational and the other merely behavioural.
A useful way to hold the difference is that the two traditions offer different starting questions:
- Greenberg: What is becoming important or threatening in this contact, and how is the person maintaining safety?
- TA: What patterns and expectations might be shaping this exchange, and how can we make contact in a way the person can use?
The questions can sit alongside each other. Neither needs to take precedence over the client’s own understanding.
What might this look like in therapy?
Suppose a client becomes quieter after the therapist says, “I feel as though we’re getting closer.”
A therapist drawing on Greenberg might wonder whether the comment has altered the client’s sense of safety. Has something that felt comfortable begun to feel intrusive? Does the client have enough room to say that the therapist’s experience is not the same as their own?
A therapist drawing on TA might also wonder about established expectations around closeness and about the transaction between them. What did the therapist intend? How was the comment received? Is there a familiar pressure to respond in a particular way?
In either case, the therapist might slow down and say:
“I noticed it became a little quieter after I said that. I’m wondering how it landed for you, but there’s no need to have an answer straight away.”
The client might say they felt uncomfortable. They might say they were simply thinking. They might disagree that anything changed. Each response matters more than fitting the moment into a theory.
The aim is not to make the person disclose more, become more sociable or give up their need for privacy. It is to make room for choice: to discover what contact feels like, where its limits are, and whether different ways of relating become possible when those limits are respected.
A final thought
Elinor Greenberg and the TA personality adaptations tradition both offer compassionate ways of thinking about withdrawal, independence and the need for safety. Their language differs, and their theories should not be treated as interchangeable. But each can help a therapist remain curious about the meaning of distance rather than assuming that it is a lack of feeling.
Perhaps the question is not, “How do we bring this person out of their shell?” It is, “What would allow this person to feel safe enough to decide how close they want to be?”
References and further reading
- Greenberg, E. (2016). Borderline, Narcissistic, and Schizoid Adaptations: The Pursuit of Love, Admiration, and Safety. ISBN 1-5373-3422-0.
- [1] Greenberg, E. “Love, Admiration, or Safety: A System of Gestalt Diagnosis of Borderline, Narcissistic, and Schizoid Adaptations that Focuses on What Is Figure for the Client.”
- [2] Ware, P. (1983). “Personality Adaptations: Doors to Therapy.” Transactional Analysis Journal, 13(1).
- [3] Little, R. “Schizoid Processes: Working with the Defenses of the Withdrawn Child Ego State.” Institute for Integrative Psychotherapy.
- Joines, V. and Stewart, I. (2002). Personality Adaptations: A New Guide to Human Understanding in Psychotherapy and Counselling. Nottingham: Lifespace Publishing.
Editorial note: This article draws on Greenberg’s published paper and summary alongside the TA sources cited; it is not a review based on a complete reading of her book.
