Choosing the Right Psychotherapy Modality

Watercolour illustration of a therapist and client in a warm consulting room, symbolising different approaches to psychotherapy.

Written by John Dray

I am a trainee psychotherapist working with compassion and affirmation within the LGBTQ+ community.

https://johndray.com

Mental Health and Wellbeing Articles | Psychotherapy Approaches

CBT | Humanistic Therapy | Integrative Therapy | Psychodynamic Therapy | Psychotherapy | Relational Therapy | Therapy Modalities

21st September 2025

Picking the Correct Psychotherapy Modality for Your Particular Issue

Psychotherapy isn’t one-size-fits-all. With a range of modalities available—from Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT) to psychodynamic, humanistic, integrative and relational approaches—selecting the right one can feel overwhelming. This guide will help you understand different therapies, evaluate your unique needs, and partner with a therapist who can best support your journey.

Understand Your Issue

Every modality shines in particular contexts:
• Anxiety and phobias: CBT is often first-line, using structured techniques to challenge unhelpful thoughts.
• Depression: Both CBT and psychodynamic approaches have strong evidence, but humanistic or relational therapy may suit those emphasising emotional connection.
• Trauma: Trauma-focused CBT, EMDR and relational therapies that focus on the therapeutic bond can be especially beneficial.

Clarify your primary concern—symptom relief, insight exploration, relationship patterns—before choosing a modality.

Overview of Common Modalities

1. Cognitive Behavioural Therapy (CBT)  
    A structured, time-limited approach targeting thought and behaviour patterns to alleviate symptoms.
2. Psychodynamic Therapy  
    Explores unconscious processes and past experiences to unearth the roots of current difficulties.
3. Humanistic Therapy  
    Emphasises self-actualisation and personal growth, often using client-centred techniques.
4. Integrative Therapy  
    Blends techniques from multiple schools to tailor treatment to individual needs and goals⁽¹⁾.
5. Relational Therapy  
    Prioritises the therapeutic relationship itself as the vehicle for change, focusing on interpersonal dynamics⁽²⁾.

Key Factors to Consider

• Evidence Base: Review research support for your issue and each modality.  
• Therapist Expertise: Choose a therapist accredited in your chosen approach.  
• Personal Style: Some prefer highly structured sessions (CBT), others value open exploration (psychodynamic/relational).  
• Practicalities: Consider availability, cost, session length and whether in-person or online suits you best.

Integrative Therapy: A Flexible Approach

Integrative therapy empowers therapists to draw on diverse techniques—cognitive, behavioural, psychodynamic, humanistic—to meet you where you are. It’s ideal if:
• You have multiple issues (e.g., anxiety plus relationship difficulties).
• You value flexibility over strict adherence to one school.
• You wish to combine symptom-focused work with deeper insight.

“Integration allows the therapist to tailor interventions relationally, clinically and culturally.” — Norcross & Goldfried, Handbook of Psychotherapy Integration

Relational Therapy: Focus on the Therapeutic Relationship

Relational therapy centres the bond between you and your therapist as the agent of change. It’s particularly useful when:
• Interpersonal patterns (e.g., attachment issues) are at the heart of your distress.
• You’ve tried techniques-focused therapies but still feel unheard.
• You value a warm, empathic connection as part of healing.

Research shows that the quality of the therapeutic alliance predicts outcomes across modalities⁽⁴⁾.

Making Your Choice

1. Assess Your Goals: Symptom relief, self-understanding, relationship repair?
2. Investigate Therapists: Read bios, ask about modality training and treatment style.
3. Arrange an Initial Session: Many offer a free consultation to gauge fit.
4. Remain Flexible: It’s okay to switch modalities if your first choice doesn’t resonate.

Conclusion

Choosing the right psychotherapy modality is a collaborative, informed process. By weighing your specific issues, therapist expertise and the core principles of each approach—especially integrative and relational therapies—you’ll be better equipped to embark on a path of meaningful change.

⸻

References
1. Norcross, J. C. & Goldfried, M. R. (2005). Handbook of Psychotherapy Integration. Oxford University Press.
2. Gelso, C. J. & Carter, J. A. (1994). Components of the psychotherapy relationship. In A. E. Bergin & S. L. Garfield (Eds.), Handbook of Psychotherapy and Behaviour Change (4th ed.). Wiley.
3. Wampold, B. E. (2015). The Great Psychotherapy Debate (2nd ed.). Routledge.
4. British Association for Counselling and Psychotherapy. “Types of Therapy.” BACP. Available: https://www.bacp.co.uk/about-therapies/types-of-therapy

The ideas, ownership and copyright of this post are the author’s. The article may have been drafted with AI assistance.