Understanding Shame
Shame is a deeply painful emotion that arises when we feel we are fundamentally flawed or unworthy of acceptance, love, or belonging. It differs from guilt in that guilt often pertains to regret over a specific action—“I did something wrong”—while shame is a pervasive feeling that “I am wrong.” Shame can make individuals want to hide or withdraw, leading to isolation and further emotional distress.
From early childhood into adulthood, shame often arises in interpersonal contexts. If someone experiences repeated criticism, rejection, or humiliation, they may internalize the message that something is wrong with who they are. Over time, this internalization can become a pervasive sense of shame that can inhibit healthy relationships and self-expression.
The Relational Perspective on Shame
Relational psychotherapy sees human beings as inherently social and shaped by the relationships in their lives. In this view, shame is not merely an internal “flaw” of the individual; it is often constructed and reinforced in relational contexts. When someone feels shame, they may believe they are unlovable or fundamentally “bad,” often because they have perceived such feedback from important relationships or societal pressures.
Key Principles of Relational Psychotherapy
- Mutuality: The therapeutic relationship is central to healing. Therapist and client engage in an authentic, two-person experience.
- Curiosity and Empathy: The therapist actively demonstrates understanding, acceptance, and empathy toward the client’s experience, helping to counteract shame by offering a validating relationship.
- Collaboration: Therapist and client work together to uncover and understand patterns of shame, including how shame manifests and how it affects the client’s sense of self and connections with others.
- Focus on Present Moment: Relational therapists pay close attention to what happens in the therapy room, noticing how shame may emerge in real time during sessions.
Why Work With Shame Through Relationship?
Shame thrives in secrecy and isolation. It often convinces a person that their perceived flaws are unworthy of empathy or compassion. Because shame is typically borne out of interpersonal dynamics—hurtful comments from loved ones, bullying, social rejection—it makes sense that it is most effectively healed through new, reparative relational experiences.
In relational psychotherapy, the therapist intentionally creates a safe space of acceptance, non-judgment, and empathy. This environment offers a stark contrast to the interpersonal situations that might have originally contributed to shame. Experiencing validation and genuine curiosity about one’s internal world can be a powerful antidote to shame, because the person learns that who they are can be seen and understood, rather than judged.
Core Elements of Working With Shame Relationally
- Attunement: The therapist listens attentively and resonates with the client’s emotional states. This moment-to-moment responsiveness fosters trust and helps the client feel safe enough to explore vulnerable feelings.
-
Naming the Shame: Healing begins when a client and therapist can label shame for what it is. Bringing it out from the shadows diminishes its power. By putting words to shame, the client and therapist reduce its secrecy.
-
Exploring Origins: Clients are encouraged to investigate where their shame originated. Which relationships or experiences contributed to it? Understanding its beginnings can reduce self-blame and replace it with self-compassion.
-
Addressing Self-Talk: Shame involves a harsh inner narrative that tells a person they are fundamentally defective. Through a validating, compassionate therapeutic relationship, clients can learn to challenge and transform this inner narrative.
-
Repairing Relational Wounds: The therapist and client explore how shame might arise in the therapy relationship itself—perhaps the client worries about the therapist’s judgment or rejection. When these fears are acknowledged and safely processed, the client experiences a healing corrective emotional experience.
-
Inviting Self-Compassion: Central to the therapy is building a capacity for self-compassion—treating oneself with kindness and understanding. As self-compassion grows, shame often recedes, because the individual begins to believe they are worthy of care and belonging.
The Impact of Relational Therapy on Shame
By consistently reinforcing a climate of trust and acceptance, relational therapy helps clients rewire expectations about how others will respond to them. Over time, repeated experiences of empathy and nonjudgment begin to replace internalized shame messages. The therapy relationship itself becomes a key instrument for change, as it both:
- Reflects Back Worthiness: The therapist’s acceptance stands in contrast to the client’s internal shame. Slowly, the client internalizes a new sense of self—one that is worthy, acceptable, and capable of forming healthy relationships.
- Models Healthy Boundaries and Communication: As the client and therapist explore relational patterns, the client develops more assertive, authentic ways of relating to others. This can bolster self-esteem and counter longstanding shame.
Practical Tips for Clients and Therapists
- Cultivate Curiosity: Approach shame with curiosity instead of judgment. Ask, “What is this feeling telling me? Where does it come from?”
- Practice Self-Compassion Exercises: Regularly engage in brief self-compassion breaks—speak kindly to yourself, acknowledge suffering, and remind yourself of common humanity (“Everyone struggles at times”).
- Seek Safe Relationships Outside of Therapy: Healing is bolstered by multiple sources of support. Friends, family, or peer groups that offer understanding and validation can reinforce the work done in therapy.
- Monitor Inner Dialogue: Listen for shame-based self-statements. Challenge them by asking if there is a gentler, more accurate way to speak to yourself.
Conclusion
Shame is a powerful emotion that often keeps us feeling unworthy or fundamentally flawed. Through the lens of relational psychotherapy, working with shame is not solely about “fixing” an internal trait; rather, it involves reshaping the relational patterns and expectations that initially gave rise to shame. By consistently offering a safe, empathetic, and attuned environment, the therapeutic relationship provides an antidote to shame’s isolating messages. Clients learn—often for the first time—that they can be seen, known, and accepted, thus paving the way for deeper self-compassion and healthier, more connected relationships outside the therapy room.
References & Further Reading
– Brown, B. (2006). Shame Resilience Theory: A Grounded Theory Study on Women and Shame. Families in Society, 87(1), 43–52.
– Tangney, J. P., & Dearing, R. L. (2002). Shame and Guilt. New York, NY: Guilford Press.
– Fonagy, P., & Target, M. (2003). Psychoanalytic Theories: Perspectives from Developmental Psychopathology. London: Whurr Publishers.